Project Stratofox: Amateur Aerospace Tracking & Recovery Team

California Shuttle Debris Search Information

This page is being left as it was in April/May of 2003 for historical purposes. Further evaluation of the ballistics of STS-107 debris that was shed over California indicates most or all of them probably had enough velocity to land in Nevada. That didn't stop our interest...

With the help of computations by Rob Matson, Stratofox is currently focusing on "Debris 6" for which the most information seems to be available. It was shed from the orbiter at the California/Nevada border immediately after an unexplained but obvious flash in Columbia's ionization trail. It was believed to be the first major event in the breakup of the vehicle. Debris 6 is believed to have impacted in the area around the Nevada/Utah border. If it's ever found, it may answer some questions about what the flash was and what was going on up there 5 minutes before the breakup.

The final STS-107 accident reports showed up in late 2003 and indicated how quickly NASA's ground searches in the West were abandoned after discovery of the flight data recorder in Texas. Some people began to wonder why more effort wasn't made on a search for Debris 6. But the rainy season had arrived with Winter well on its way - it was too late to search rough terrain in 2003.

The topic came up again when Stratofox hosted a meeting for STS-107 photographers and eyewitnesses on Feb 1, 2004, the one-year anniversary of the accident. The meeting attendees included all the photographers from whom NASA learned about the debris-shedding events over California, except for one who was ill but would otherwise have been there. We began making plans for the dry season of 2004. Some Stratofox members made an initial expedition to explore the area on April 8-11, 2004.

For anyone interested in this search or performing other shuttle debris searches, we should mention these notes...

On this page...

Why is Stratofox hosting this web page?

This isn't the kind of tracking and recovery we usually do at Project Stratofox. Then again, no one seems to have a precedent for any aspect of the STS-107 Columbia space shuttle accident. This is of interest to more than enough of our team members. Our experience tracking balloon instruments flown to 100,000' and recovering them wherever they land may provide some insight about how to narrow down the incredibly huge search area for what may be just a few pieces of space shuttle debris across the State of California. We've posted this web page as information that should be useful for organizing searches, informing members of the public and as a resource for the news media.

Getting started - What we know

NASA released very detailed information about Columbia's ground track.
The accident investigation board released a very detailed timeline of events including ground track information on February 12, 2003. (It was updated Feb 21 to include points of videotaped debris separations.) If you have any difficulty reaching their site, a web search found that SpaceRef made a copy of it.

Winds aloft data tells us debris should only be north of the ground track in California.
We looked at the following information from the University of Wyoming Upper Air Soundings archive of National Weather Service (NWS) balloon data. It is necessary to find data from nearby stations at times before and after the event. In this case, they're from Feb 1, 12Z (4AM Pacific Time) to Feb 2, 00Z (Feb 1, 4PM Pacific Time). The shuttle pass was at 5:52AM to 5:54AM.

Searching for Tiles

[image of California counties in debris search area] If you'd like to participate, pay attention to the advice below for what to do in case you find a tile. You can also join the TileHunt mail list to talk with others who are looking.

On March 4, NASA listed 24 counties in California as areas to watch for shuttle debris: Alpine, Amador, Calaveras, Colusa, Contra Costa, El Dorado, Lake, Madera, Marin, Mariposa, Mendocino, Mono, Napa, Nevada, Placer, Sacramento, San Joaquin, Solano, Sonoma, Stanislaus, Sutter, Tuolumne, Yolo and Yuba.

While that area may be appropriate to notify property owners to be aware to watch for debris, we believe that is too large an area to recommend for a search effort. Efforts should be confined to within a few miles north of the STS-107 re-entry ground track.

Ballistic projections of debris impact areas

We're working on various simulations to narrow down the search area a bit. Here are some references. Some sample software... Some members of our group have their own simulation software not shown here. We're attempting to run different kinds of simulations in order to cross-check each other.

Here are the debris separation points using locations described by NASA's Re-entry Timeline 13.0. Rick Baldridge also posted a ground track based on his video cross-checked with NASA's re-entry timeline. For the initial vector, our simulations use an initial down-angle of 0 degrees 10 minutes at Columbia's rate of descent over California.

(Note that these only cover debris separations which were captured on video from the ground. It is possible that others occurred further west, though we have no data with which to project impact areas.)

name separation location initial vector rough guess
estimated 80 miles downrange
coordinates description time altitude speed heading
Debris #1 38.63113 -122.119 E of Lake Berryessa, NW of Winters, W of I-505 13:53:44-48 230348' Mach 22.88 TBD near Volcano, Amador County
Debris #2 38.62375 -122.0436 E of Lake Berryessa, NNW of Winters, W of I-505 13:53:45-49 230276' Mach 22.87 TBD SR88 at Barton, Amador County
Debris #3 38.55415 -121.3669 just E of Watt Ave and Folsom Blvd, Sacramento 13:53:54-58 229621' Mach 22.79 TBD near Donnell Lake on the Stanislaus River, Tuolumne County
above snow line as of early March
SR108 closed for Winter in this area
Debris #4 38.49604 -120.8433 1/2mi north of Plymouth, over SR49 13:54:01-05 229113' Mach 22.73 TBD 1mi S of US 395, half way between Sonora Jct (SR108) and Bridgeport, Mono County
Debris #5 38.46127 -120.5453 1/2mi NW of Barton, 1mi W of SR88 13:54:05-09 228817' Mach 22.69 TBD near Aurora Canyon Rd and Bodie Masonic Rd, Mono County
Debris #6 38.1536 -118.2653 8mi N of Basalt NV on US6, 10mi SW of Tonopah Jct on US95 13:54:34-36 226748' Mach 22.41 TBD TBD

Note that 80 miles downrange is a rough guess of the minimum flight distance of these pieces of debris, and may be many miles further downrange, but probably not less. Stay tuned while we work on our ballistics sims. These estimates will get narrowed down.

Search area accessibility and road conditions

Current highway conditions... CalTrans has a page with info on durations of mountain pass closures in previous years.

If you find a piece of shuttle debris...

If you find a piece of shuttle debris in California, it's a rare find. It would be critical information for the crash investigation, since each tile (we're assuming there will only be tiles in California) can be uniquely identified and will tell investigators where the first ones came off.

So if you find one, here are some do's and don'ts:

Don't touch it!
Keep everything as you found it for the investigators. Let people experienced in handling evidence be the first to handle it.

It probably isn't nearly the toxic hazard of the debris in Texas. Over there the falling debris may have been exposed to the contents of ruptured propellant tanks during the breakup. But since it's from the exterior of the orbiter, it was exposed to two weeks' worth of thruster exhaust in orbit. It really isn't something you want to come in contact with. If you touch it inadvertently (i.e. "what's this?"), put it back exactly the way you found it and wash your hands ASAP.

Feel free to take pictures.
Taking pictures will not disturb the debris so that's fine. The pictures will be your souvenirs of your accomplishment, so it's recommended. If you have a web site, you may even want to post them.

Make an effort to determine that it isn't just trash.
Remember, in California we think we're mainly just looking for tiles. They should be black on at least one side, otherwise beige. They'd be up to 6x6 inch squares if unbroken.

Some photos of shuttle debris from Texas are available online. NASA posted debris pictures for your reference. Tiles can vary in size but won't be larger than 6 x 6 inches square and 2 inches thick. Other released images of tiles which seemed relevant are mirrored here:

[tile image 1] (140K JPEG image)
[tile image 2] (160K JPEG image)

Another example is at the volunteer-operated debrismap.com. NASA has already been bombarded with calls regarding every bit of unrecognized trash in the West. We think we can mainly expect thermal protection tiles here in California. Let's all try to make our reports credible.

Get the GPS coordinates if possible.
This will help make sure it can be located again by investigators. If you don't have a GPS and you have to leave the area to report the debris, record everything necessary to show someone where the site is.

Protect the debris from being disturbed.
If you have to, guard/watch it until law enforcement arrives and takes over the scene.

Report it.
The California Highway Patrol is taking the lead on shuttle debris reports in the state. From a cell phone, simply call 911 and you'll get to CHP dispatch. From any land line phone, call 911 and ask for CHP.

You may also directly call NASA Johnson Space Center's Emergency Operations Center at (281) 483-3388 or send an e-mail to columbiaimages@nasa.gov.

Though NASA and the local law enforcement may not prefer this, you have the option to call the news media too. Just make sure anyone you call does not disturb it.